Sentence Auditions

Ideas and Curiosities

Month: March, 2012

Bad For Me

I’ve never wanted a child.

When I was sixteen, my best friend told me that was a good thing, because I’d probably die in childbirth. The rest of the lunch table agreed. My hips stopped growing at age twelve, leaving me with the frail frame I have still. No room for baby, and I guess at that point a c-section was beyond our scope of imagination.

Lots of my friends would prefer not to procreate. They think they’re too selfish to raise a child, that eighteen years is too long of a commitment. Most don’t think they’ll ever be able to afford one. I just think motherhood would turn me into a sour nag.

But people do have children, and my job is to write for and about those folk. At work I spend hours every day reading Mommy Blogs. Not having pushed one out myself, sometimes I am a bit terrified by what they tell me. Tales of chapped nipples and hateful children share space with tips on what to do when your kids walks in on sexy time. Reading these make me want to pack up my uterus and send it along to someone who could put it to better use.

Not all blogs by moms are like this. You might have read about the prevalence of Mormon mom blogs. Their children wear carefully coordinated prints in crayon colors. They are always smiling, and there is rarely a dirty faced child. Husbands are benefactors, breadwinners, and saints. Photos upon photos that suggest that neither runny nose nor dirt stained knee lasts for long in these houses. Everything just looks perfect, as though the pastel paradise of Edward Scissorhands had covered America with a benevolent wave of domestic bliss.

Do I believe that these parcels of perfection truly exist on our planet? Of course not. I know that these living Pinterest boards are creations. That the woman blogging are sharing only the crests of their lives. Why do they do it? Are they advertising for the Mormon faith? Maybe, but I don’t think that’s enough to explain them. From my ever-skeptic vantage, I believe these blogs serve to soothe the mothers who write them. Just as anyone who has spent any amount of time consciously crafting their Facebook page might scroll down its photos, witticisms, and videos with a sigh of self-satisfaction, so to do these mothers. We create a persona for ourselves online that matches the person we’d most like to be. Nothing revolutionary here. And yet…

I am most vulnerable when I’m lonely. Sometimes when I deep down, I want to populate the world with people who are bound to love me. Perhaps you’ve exhausted the options. No one came to your dinner parties, you hated everyone at the book club. Party nights leave you empty and you haven’t felt exhilaration in days. Good things happen, but they do so at a regular, predictable pace. Short of a windfall of wealth and companionship, there’s not much light left for you beyond the drudgery. These blogs try to swoop in right when I’m in my trough, try to trick me into thinking that Mother’s Little Helper is actually just the baby herself.

But I know better, and I snap out of it and remind myself how much I’d hate to carry a child. To calm myself down and make myself feel better about the “me” I am already, it often helps to take a scroll down my Facebook page…

Hunger Games

SPOILERS? Yes.

Though known for gore, The Hunger Games‘ strength lies in its rendering of complex moral issues in a period of state upheaval.

It steals luster from the good and evil magical realism I treasure. In Pan’s Labyrinth, the Spanish Civil War is a story of bad men hurting families. In Life Is Beautiful, there are bad Nazis and victimized Jews. It’s not that the bad guys in those films weren’t bad, and they were certainly committing terrible deeds. And of course the protagonists are noble, strong, and sympathetic. That’s the problem. They provide an unrealistic and an unhelpful model for behavior in the face of oppression, one that few could hope to emulate with such ease.

Hunger Games, however, looks closer at the composition of “the bad guys”, and examines how difficult it can be to tell who they are. Not only that, the series doesn’t gloss over the negative traits that can come along heroism. Katniss is at times paranoid, self-centered, and insensitive. Whether her initial hesitation to accept the Mockingbird mantle is a sign of immaturity or wisdom isn’t made clear for readers. This ambiguity carries through the series’ conclusion.

When Katniss shoots President Coin, leader of rebel stronghold District 13, it is a miracle that readers still remain loyal to her. Collins, clunky as her writing can sometimes be, is a deft moral analyst with little sympathy for complacent or power-hungry characters.  Haymitch, drunken mentor to Katniss, says to his protegee: “Remember who the real enemy is.” It is advice readers must heed constantly, and Collins doesn’t let them forget that. She speaks through Katniss, who always doubts the adults trying to use her as a mouthpiece for their rebel movement. At risk of becoming a didactic skeptic, Katniss manages to be a tolerable and memorable protagonist. As readers, we don’t always know whether our narrator rightly dismisses characters like Coin, or if she is simply being paranoid. After all, Katniss is an angsty teenager with severe psychological issues. She does not trust the allies Haymitch has made for her, including Johanna. Most readers, however, will understand that she is not the enemy so much as the capitol is. On the other hand, Katniss’ immediate distrust of Coin is more difficult to approach. So much lies at stake for Coin and her people, and so it is not surprising that she would care so much about the precise outcome of each step of the rebellion. That she nearly suffocates her champion’s drive and spirit is forgivable.

It is only when the Capitol has fallen and Coin has taken leadership of Panem that it is irrefutably clear that she fought not for the people of Panem, but for herself (and, to a lesser extent, the people of District 13). I would love to think that a generation of Hunger Games readers will emerge from reading the book with a healthy skepticism of political personalities, and with a better understanding of the difficult decisions, not to mention atrocities, confronted by citizens of a dictatorial state.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.